Danielle Kubes is a trained journalist and investor who has written about personal finance for the past six years. Her writing has been published in The Globe and Mail, National Post, MoneySense, Vice and RateHub.ca. Danielle writes about investing and personal finance for Wealthsimple. She has a Bachelor of Humanities from Carleton University and a Master of Journalism from Ryerson University.
Leveraged exchange-traded funds, or ETFs, use the same principle: They borrow money to try to double or triple any movement in their benchmark in a particular day. That means when you win, you win big and when you lose, well, it’s not pretty.
Previously, anyone interested in leveraging ETFs would have to borrow money in a margin account, take out a line of credit or get an investment loan and use that to buy a traditional ETF. To make money, their rate of return would have to exceed the interest on the debt. However, these new products do all the borrowing inside the fund so you don’t have to worry about interest or dealing with a margin call. In other words, you can capture all the gains of a leveraged investments without the possibility of losing anything more than your principle. It’s a lower-risk way to do something pretty risky to begin with.Grow your money with low fees and no account minimums. Invest as little as a dollar and we’ll build you a personalized investment portfolio to meet your financial goals.
Pros and cons of leveraged ETFs
Good alternative to taking out an investment loan since you can’t lose more than you invest and don’t have to deal with margin calls
Liquid investment, just like any other ETF
Easy to purchase by searching its ticker on the stock exchange, just like any other ETF
Saves on gas from driving to a casino
Time-consuming research and analysis needed
Must remember to buy and sell your investments each day
CRA frowns on day-trading in registered accounts, so you’ll have a massive headache come tax time keeping up with all of your capital gains and losses
Commission gets expensive when trading daily and cuts into returns
Leveraged ETFs borrow money through complicated derivative techniques that few understand, and you should never buy an investment you don’t understand
What is a leveraged ETF
To understand exactly how leveraged ETFs work, we first have to understand the fundamentals of how a standard ETF uses an index.
You know when you turn on the news and you hear the anchor saying in a slightly panicked tone that the Dow dropped by 100 points? It seems really important but you have no clue what it actually means? Well, all that cable news station is blaring on about is the performance of a group of 30 massive companies in the U.S.—an index titled Dow Jones Industrial Average. It’s not a stock in itself, although it moves up or down based on the performance of the stocks it holds.
There are many more of these indices, each holding a collection of stocks that measures the performance of a particular sector or slice of the financial markets.
There’s no set number of stocks or bonds an index can hold—it can be a handful or hundreds.
You don’t invest directly in an index, but you can invest in ETFs, a financial product that attempts to mimic an index. ETFs do this by buying up all the securities in the index in equal weighting and use the index as a point of reference to duplicate their performance. You can judge if an ETF is doing its job by checking how closely its performance matches its benchmark.
So if the benchmark goes up 5% a year, then the ETF should, too. And if it goes down 5%, then the ETF will fall. Traditional ETFs act don’t try to do better than their benchmark—instead it’s like being taken on a boat ride and rising and falling with the tides.
They simply seek to match a specific index by purchasing and holding the securities in the index they’re trying to duplicate. Like mutual funds they allow investors to diversify through a single holding, because that holding acts like a basket, itself holding multiple securities. Unlike mutual funds, they rarely have human managers making buying and selling decisions and don’t try to reach a performance target. Instead, they use an algorithm to simply duplicate their benchmark without trying to outperform it. They charge a low administrative fee that reflects their hands-off approach.
How leveraged ETFs work
But ETFs proved such a popular financial product that they’ve produced spin-offs, many which have little resemblance to the original. One of these new products are leveraged ETFs, which seek not to match, but to exceed, their benchmark’s daily performance through betting larger, borrowed sums.
Leveraged ETFs can’t really be compared to traditional ETFs. Traditional ETFs are a passively managed, easy method for novice or busy investors to build wealth over decades. Leveraged ETFs are heavily managed, speculative, risky, and extremely short-term investments—they’re meant to be held for a single day. The managers get financing and rebalance the securities every morning to reach their goal. To reflect the active administration, fees are much more expensive than traditional ETFs.
Some ETFs even try to triple-leverage your investment, or return 300% of the benchmark’s daily performance. That sounds pretty good until you consider that a benchmark index can easily go down, which means you’ve just amplified any losses by 300%.
Unlike traditional ETFs, which are suitable for any investor with a low-to-medium risk tolerance and minimal knowledge, these complex financial products are only suitable for sophisticated investors who like a thrill and who have money they don’t mind losing.
Examples of leverage ETFs
New leveraged ETF products emerge every day. It’s difficult to evaluate them because, like any risky stock, that evaluation requires a deep analysis. A leveraged ETF’s risk level is not only dependent on the fact that they’re taking on debt, but also on what benchmark they’re aligning with. It could be that a leveraged ETF that uses a diversified, large cap benchmark is actually less risky than buying a traditional ETF that tracks a volatile, new sector.
Let’s take a quick look at some real life examples of leveraged ETFs to get a better understanding of how this works.
Both of the following ETFs are using the S&P/TSX 60 as a benchmark, which contains some of the biggest, most established companies in Canada who have a long—often centuries-long—history of profit. We’re talking all the big banks, Suncor and the Canada National Railway. The daily movements are often under 1%.
Horizons HXU tries to gain 200% over the returns of the benchmark every day, before a management and administrative cost of 1.15%.Comparatively, iShares XIU, which tracks the identical index sans leverage, charges just 0.35%, almost 70% cheaper.
It’s difficult to compare the performance of each since the HXU measures it’s performance daily, and the XIU over years. On a good day, with a rise of 1%, HXU would return $300 on $10,000 while XIU would only return $100. But on a bad day, with a decline of 1%, HXU would cost you $300 whereas with XIU you’d only be down $100. Since all research has determined that active management does not beat the market over the long term, it’s likely you’d end up richer had you just bought and held XIU.
Let’s take another, much more niche and volatile index: the North American Marijuana sector which opened in just 2017 and can easily move 6 to 20% in a single day.
Horizon developed an ETF, HMJU, that uses leverage to beat the index twice over and also has an ETF, HMMJ, that mostly tracks it. Both have higher than average management fees, at 1.45% and .75% respectively. Since the marijuana industry only recently emerged and the valuations and funding are precarious and uncertain, both ETFs are considered high-risk. Furthermore, both ETFs lack true diversification because all the securities share the same asset class and industry.
When you add leverage, on top of an already shaky industry, it’s really anyone’s guess what will happen (that’s likely why Horizon added yet another ETF, one that uses leverage to bet against the rise of the industry.) Since the swings in this index are so much more dramatic than established sectors you could hit a serious home run investing in either ETF, or equally as possible reach rock bottom. The problem is, there’s no way of telling which.
Should you invest in leveraged ETFs
Top investing professionals, like Warren Buffet himself, recommend the best way to build wealth for retirement is to consistently stash cash in an ETF that tracks around 500 of the largest U.S. companies. That way you’re not placing any bets on the fate of a particular company but rather betting on the U.S. economy itself. The theory is that over the very long term, 30 to 50 years, the economy will have grown, although day to day, and year to year and even decade to decade, movement will vary dramatically.
The same does not apply to leveraged ETFs.
By nature, leveraged ETFs are short-term investments. Nevertheless, they may have a place in your portfolio if you’re a seasoned investor and fully understand how they work. If you have the time to day trade and set aside a specific set of money in your portfolio to “play” with, it may work for you.Wealthsimple Invest is an automated way to grow your money like the worlds most sophisticated investors. Get started and we'll build you a personalized investment portfolio in a matter of minutes.