Skip to main content

Sole proprietorship vs. corporation: when to incorporate

Updated

If you run a small business in Canada, one of the first structural decisions you face is how to set it up. Comparing a sole proprietorship vs a corporation in Canada usually comes down to a trade-off: a sole proprietorship is simple and inexpensive to run, while a corporation adds liability protection and tax-planning options at the cost of more money and paperwork.

There is no universal answer. The right choice depends on your income, the risks in your line of work, and where you want the business to go. If you have ever asked yourself "when should I incorporate," the honest response is that it depends on your numbers and your goals. This article walks through how each structure works so you can have a more informed conversation with a qualified Canadian accountant, who should confirm the decision before you act.

What is a sole proprietorship?

A sole proprietorship is the simplest way to run a business. It is not a separate legal entity, so the owner and the business are considered the same. That means the owner carries unlimited personal liability for business debts.

In practice, you keep the profits, you report them on your personal taxes, and you are personally responsible for anything the business owes. Many freelancers, consultants, and side-business owners start here because it is quick and cheap to begin.

What is a corporation?

A corporation is a legal entity that is separate from its owners. It can own property, sign contracts, and sue or be sued in its own name. Under Canadian law, it has the same rights and obligations as a natural person, and that is what gives its shareholders limited liability.

Because the corporation is separate from you, your business and personal finances are legally distinct. That separation is the source of most of the benefits and most of the added paperwork.

Sole proprietorship vs. corporation in Canada: key differences

Here is a side-by-side look at how the two structures compare.

Sole proprietorship
Corporation
Legal status/separationNo separation; you and the business are oneSeparate legal entity from its owners
Personal liabilityUnlimited personal liability for debtsLimited liability, with some exceptions
How it's taxedReported on your personal T1 returnFiles its own T2 corporate return
Setup cost and effortLow cost, minimal stepsHigher cost, more steps
Paperwork/adminLighter record-keepingOngoing filings and corporate records
Raising moneyLimited to personal funds and loansCan issue shares to raise capital
ContinuityEnds with the ownerCan continue beyond any one owner

Liability: who is responsible for business debts?

This is often the deciding factor. In a sole proprietorship, there is no legal wall between you and the business. Because the owner and the business are the same, the owner is personally liable for all the debts and obligations of the business. If the business cannot pay, creditors can pursue your personal assets.

A corporation changes that. As a separate legal entity, a corporation gives its shareholders limited liability, which generally means they are not personally responsible for the corporation's debts.

Limited liability is real, but it is not absolute. There are well-known exceptions. Directors can be held personally liable for unremitted payroll source deductions and unremitted Goods and Services Tax / Harmonized Sales Tax (GST/HST), and lenders frequently require personal guarantees before extending credit to a small corporation. In other words, incorporating does not shield you from every claim, so it helps to understand where the protection stops.

Taxes: how each structure is taxed

Tax treatment is where the two structures differ the most, so it is worth taking slowly.

How a sole proprietorship is taxed

A sole proprietorship does not file its own return. As a sole proprietor, you report business income on your personal T1 income tax return using Form T2125, Statement of Business or Professional Activities, which you file with the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA). That income is taxed at your personal marginal rates, the same brackets that apply to employment income. In a high-earning year, that can push a meaningful share of your profit into the top brackets.

How a corporation is taxed

A corporation is a separate taxpayer. All resident corporations must file a T2 corporate income tax return every tax year, even if there is no tax payable.

The appeal for many small businesses is the lower corporate rate on active business income. For Canadian-controlled private corporations (CCPCs) claiming the small business deduction (SBD), the net federal tax rate is 9% on the first $500,000 of active business income. Income above that amount is taxed at the 15% general federal rate. Once you add provincial and territorial rates, combined small business rates reach up to about 12.2% across the provinces and territories, and the combined general rate on income above $500,000 can reach about 30%.

That lower rate is what makes tax deferral possible. The small business corporate rate of up to roughly 12.2% sits well below the top personal marginal rates that apply to higher incomes. So keeping profit inside the corporation lets you defer personal tax on the money you do not need to live on. This is a deferral, not a permanent saving: personal tax applies when you withdraw the money. The benefit shows up most when your business earns more than you spend.

Paying yourself: salary vs. dividends

If you incorporate, you choose how to pay yourself, and the two main options behave differently. Salary is taxed at your personal rates, creates Registered Retirement Savings Plan (RRSP) contribution room, and requires Canada Pension Plan (CPP) contributions. Dividends get a lower personal rate because the corporation has already paid tax on that income, so the total tax is designed to end up roughly similar. They create no RRSP room and no CPP contributions. Neither is automatically better; the right mix depends on your situation, which is a conversation to have with your accountant.

CPP is part of this choice too. As a sole proprietor, you pay both the employee and employer portions of the CPP, a combined rate of 11.90%, compared with 5.95% for an employee. That isn't a cost only sole proprietors carry. If you incorporate and pay yourself a salary, you pay your portion and the corporation pays its portion. Dividends are what skip CPP.

One rule often surprises new incorporators. The Tax on Split Income (TOSI) rules have been in effect since 2018. Under them, dividends paid to family members who are not genuinely involved in the business are generally taxed at the top marginal rate, subject to a limited set of exclusions. So the older idea of freely "sprinkling" dividends to lower-income relatives no longer works the way it once did.

Cost and admin: what each structure requires

A sole proprietorship is light on both cost and record-keeping. You track income and expenses, keep your receipts, and file Form T2125 with your personal return.

A corporation asks for more. You incorporate, maintain corporate records, and file a T2 return every year even in a year with no profit. You also need bookkeeping that keeps corporate and personal money cleanly separated.

On fees, you have a federal or a provincial path. Incorporating federally online under the Canada Business Corporations Act costs $200, plus a $12 annual return filed each year. Provincial and territorial incorporation fees vary by jurisdiction.

Can a sole proprietor invest business money?

Both structures can hold investments, but the tax results differ.

Investing as a sole proprietor

A sole proprietor invests through personal accounts (TFSA, RRSP, FHSA or non-registered), since there's no separate business to hold investments. Any investment income is simply yours, reported on your personal return and taxed at your personal rates. The business and the owner are one, so there is no corporate layer to plan around.

Investing inside a corporation

A corporation can hold investments too, but passive income faces extra rules. Passive investment income is taxed at high rates inside a CCPC, and it can also cost you the lower small business rate on your active business income. Earning more than $50,000 of adjusted aggregate investment income in a year begins to grind down the next year's $500,000 small business limit, the amount of active business income that qualifies for the small business deduction. Once that investment income reaches $150,000, the limit drops to $0, and all of your active business income is taxed at the full general corporate rate. For a business that plans to hold significant investments, this is worth modelling with an accountant.

When should you incorporate?

There is no single income figure where incorporating always makes sense. It is a planning judgment that weighs your profit, your liability exposure, and your longer-term plans, and it is one an accountant should help you make.

Signs it may be time to incorporate

A few patterns tend to prompt the conversation:

  • Your business consistently earns more than you need to live on, so tax deferral could help.

  • Your work carries real liability risk, and limited liability would offer some protection.

  • You want to bring in partners or investors, which a corporation can accommodate through shares.

  • You want the business to continue beyond your personal involvement.

None of these guarantees that incorporating is right for you. They are prompts to run the numbers with a professional.

Should you incorporate as a freelancer?

Many freelancers wonder whether they should incorporate as a freelancer or stay a sole proprietor. If your income is modest, variable, or still ramping up, the simplicity and low cost of a sole proprietorship often fit the stage you are in. As your profit grows and becomes steadier, the tax-deferral and liability benefits of a corporation start to carry more weight. The turning point is specific to your finances, so treat it as a question for your accountant rather than a fixed rule.

How to switch from a sole proprietorship to a corporation

You do not convert a sole proprietorship directly. Instead, you incorporate a new company and transfer your business assets into it. A Section 85 rollover under the Income Tax Act lets you transfer eligible assets to your corporation on a tax-deferred basis, using Form T2057.

Keep in mind that the rollover defers tax; it does not eliminate it. You will also need to re-register the accounts tied to your business, including GST/HST, payroll, and banking, under the new corporation. Because the paperwork and the election have lasting tax consequences, this is a step to complete with a qualified Canadian Chartered Professional Accountant (CPA).

Which structure is right for you?

A sole proprietorship rewards simplicity: low cost, light paperwork, and everything reported on your personal return. A corporation rewards scale: limited liability, a lower rate on active business income, and room to defer and plan, in exchange for higher cost and more administration.

If your business is small, steady, and lower-risk, the sole proprietorship may serve you well for now. If profit is growing, risk is rising, or you are planning for partners and longevity, incorporating may earn its keep. The deciding factors are your own numbers and goals, and an accountant should confirm the decision before you register anything.

Wealthsimple’s Learn pages are meant to be educational. Every story is sourced from and vetted by subject matter experts, and produced by journalists with decades of media experience — people whose primary goal is to teach you something, rather than sell you something. While there may be links included in the article about products that are offered by Wealthsimple Investments Inc. (“Wealthsimple”) or one of its affiliates, these articles are not investment advice, a recommendation to buy or sell assets or securities, or any other kind of professional advice. If you are interested in learning about how Wealthsimple products or features work, please visit the Help Centre. If you are interested in knowing which products are offered by Wealthsimple and which are offered by affiliates, we’ve got a page to help you with that, too.

Frequently asked questions

Can I turn my sole proprietorship into a corporation?

Not directly. You incorporate a new company and transfer your business assets into it. A Section 85 rollover can move eligible assets on a tax-deferred basis using Form T2057. You then re-register accounts such as GST/HST, payroll, and banking, ideally with a CPA's help.

Does Canada have limited liability companies?

No. Canada does not have limited liability companies (LLCs). Canadian business owners generally choose among a sole proprietorship, a partnership, or a corporation. The LLC is a United States structure without a direct Canadian equivalent.

Is a corporation better than a sole proprietorship?

Neither is better in the abstract; they suit different situations. A sole proprietorship is simpler and cheaper, while a corporation adds limited liability and tax-planning options along with more cost and paperwork. The right fit depends on your income, risk, and goals, so confirm it with an accountant.

Do I need to register for GST/HST?

Often, yes, once you pass the small supplier threshold. You must register for GST/HST once your total taxable revenues exceed $30,000 in a single calendar quarter or over four consecutive calendar quarters.

Build your own portfolio your way with stocks, ETFs, and options