--- title: "“Priced in”: How the News Drives Stocks — and How It Doesn’t" description: "The news affects stock prices, just not in the way individual investors often think." url: "https://www.wealthsimple.com/en-ca/magazine/priced-in-explainer-2024" lastUpdated: "2025-02-17" --- ![ABC](/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto,quality=75,width=3072,fit=scale-down/https://images.ctfassets.net/v44fuld738we/NzTFOooFeAmDQIxCHOHED/b5da1e966b94fbb1ad05ef057e720614/TLDR_Art_App_1080x720_091624__1_.jpg) ABC Finance for Humans # “Priced in”: How the News Drives Stocks — and How It Doesn’t Headlines can move share prices, but individual investors often don’t understand why. Written ByBen Mathis-Lilley onFebruary 17, 2025 **_Wealthsimple_** makes powerful financial tools to help you grow and manage your money. [Learn more](/en-ca) What’s the biggest mistake investors make? It depends on who you ask, because [investors mess up in all sorts of ways](https://www.investopedia.com/articles/stocks/07/beat_the_mistakes.asp). But a [new study](https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4589777) by a team of (slightly judgmental) Germans suggests that _individual_ investors — that is, non-pros who manage their own money — are likely to make one big error over and over. That error is that they fail to understand what it means for expectations to be “priced in” to the cost of a company’s stock. And, since there are a lot of big expectations priced into stocks right now — like that tech companies will keep growing profits by a lot — we thought it would be a good time to explain the blunder. ## Recommended for you * ![](/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto,quality=75,width=3072,fit=scale-down/https://images.ctfassets.net/v44fuld738we/4dHBnjix0kuvPmp5GZY6Nc/ca6d5240960d5701dd4f0a8032957936/TLDR_Art_App_1080x720_030325__1_.jpg) [Did You Lose Money Trading Stocks? Blame Your Caveman Brain](/en-ca/magazine/trading-bias) Finance for Humans * ![](/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto,quality=75,width=3072,fit=scale-down/https://images.ctfassets.net/v44fuld738we/4OOgI2dDbcT5L23NM3kUfb/038d583e00d358715f27f6c45d86ba7f/News_1900x1900_Magazine_Square_Hero1.png) [Is the Stock Market Finally, Actually Overvalued?](/en-ca/magazine/free-cash-flow) Finance for Humans * ![](/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto,quality=75,width=3072,fit=scale-down/https://images.ctfassets.net/v44fuld738we/3lx7Vg6VPElMeruHaHv9Sc/84dcd215e2585f89affe904424564ac9/DefensiveStocks_1900x1900_Magazine_Square.png) [Markets Have Been Bananas. Is It Time to Hold Defensive Stocks?](/en-ca/magazine/defensive-stocks) Finance for Humans * ![](/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto,quality=75,width=3072,fit=scale-down/https://images.ctfassets.net/v44fuld738we/6szCndKocIlQkHUrBbawm5/58b57d9e42bb422dac403a1222d78b2c/Diversification_1900x1900_Magazine_Square_Fallback__1_.jpg) [How Do I Diversify, Anyway?](/en-ca/magazine/how-do-i-diversify) Finance for Humans **First, what does “priced in” mean?** It’s easiest to explain with an example: back in 2020–2021, Tesla shares soared not because the company was already making mountains of cash (it wasn’t) but because investors _expected_ it to as EV demand grew. So its future performance was reflected in its stock price — aka it was priced in. That’s why, though Tesla has earned [billions this year](https://www.theverge.com/2024/4/23/24134282/tesla-earnings-q1-2024-profit-demand-elon-musk), its stock hasn’t risen; the earnings were expected. Tesla would have needed to _beat_ expectations for its stock price to rise, and it hasn’t done that so far. Just the opposite, in fact: its stock price has fallen because earnings have come in lower than anticipated. **What did the Germans find out?** So three German researchers did an experiment. They told a group of individual investors (aka retail investors) about some hypothetical news reports — some positive, some negative — that stood to affect a company’s revenues. Then they asked what effect the news would have on a $1,000 investment into said company _a month after the news broke_. In response, most individual investors said that they would expect a $1,000 investment to grow in light of the month-old positive news and to fall in light of bad news.  The problem with this answer is that, in most cases, after a full month the price of the stock would have already changed in response to the news — that is, the information would already be priced in. But the novice investors assumed that the stock’s price would continue to go up (or down) in the future because it had gone up (or down) a month earlier, when that might not necessarily be the case.  **What’s the lesson?** Being right about how well or poorly a company’s business is doing right now isn’t how you make money trading its stock. To make a return, you have to invest in companies that make money _and_ beat expectations. Everyone knows, for instance, that Apple makes great products and generates a lot of money. But for its stock to rise, it needs to make a _surprisingly_ large amount of money. And it’s hard to guess which companies will do that! You have to correctly surmise that the market hasn’t priced in something important about the future or has undervalued a stock for some reason. We know we say this often, but the difficulty of picking which companies will beat expectations is why many smart people, like Warren Buffett, suggest individual investors buy not individual stocks but [diversified index funds](https://www.dimensional.com/us-en/insights/five-things-i-know-about-investing), which bet on hundreds of companies. If you are going to trade individual stocks, though, you’d be wise to ask yourself two questions first: \[1\] do other investors have high or low expectations for a company and why? (A company’s [forward price-to-earnings ratio](https://corporatefinanceinstitute.com/resources/valuation/forward-pe-ratio/#) can speak to this.) And \[2\] do you have a better view of the company’s future performance than the rest of the market? If you can’t answer both, perhaps think twice before submitting the trade. ![author](/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto,quality=75,width=128,fit=scale-down/https://images.ctfassets.net/v44fuld738we/2B2CHzgWTMvsFcdZo4S1lf/8a5e56a71cf3aac924689e7142efb55b/Ben_Mathis-Lilley_head_shot_color3.jpg) Written By Ben Mathis-Lilley Ben Mathis-Lilley is a senior writer for [Slate.com](http://slate.com/) and the author of[The Hot Seat: A Year of Outrage, Pride, and Occasional Games of College Football](https://www.hachettebookgroup.com/titles/ben-mathis-lilley/the-hot-seat/9781541700352/?lens=publicaffairs). He's also written for BuzzFeed and New York magazine. ## Recommended for you * ![](/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto,quality=75,width=3072,fit=scale-down/https://images.ctfassets.net/v44fuld738we/4dHBnjix0kuvPmp5GZY6Nc/ca6d5240960d5701dd4f0a8032957936/TLDR_Art_App_1080x720_030325__1_.jpg) [Did You Lose Money Trading Stocks? Blame Your Caveman Brain](/en-ca/magazine/trading-bias) Finance for Humans * ![](/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto,quality=75,width=3072,fit=scale-down/https://images.ctfassets.net/v44fuld738we/4OOgI2dDbcT5L23NM3kUfb/038d583e00d358715f27f6c45d86ba7f/News_1900x1900_Magazine_Square_Hero1.png) [Is the Stock Market Finally, Actually Overvalued?](/en-ca/magazine/free-cash-flow) Finance for Humans * ![](/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto,quality=75,width=3072,fit=scale-down/https://images.ctfassets.net/v44fuld738we/3lx7Vg6VPElMeruHaHv9Sc/84dcd215e2585f89affe904424564ac9/DefensiveStocks_1900x1900_Magazine_Square.png) [Markets Have Been Bananas. Is It Time to Hold Defensive Stocks?](/en-ca/magazine/defensive-stocks) Finance for Humans * ![](/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto,quality=75,width=3072,fit=scale-down/https://images.ctfassets.net/v44fuld738we/6szCndKocIlQkHUrBbawm5/58b57d9e42bb422dac403a1222d78b2c/Diversification_1900x1900_Magazine_Square_Fallback__1_.jpg) [How Do I Diversify, Anyway?](/en-ca/magazine/how-do-i-diversify) Finance for Humans Share TWITTERFACEBOOKCopy link ## Related articles Money Diaries > "MY UNDERGRADUATE ADVISER TOLD ME I SHOULD JUST FORGET ABOUT THE WHOLE WRITING THING. ‘YOU SHOULD FIND A GOOD MAN AND GET MARRIED,’ HE TOLD ME." Margaret Atwood [Read Article](/en-ca/magazine/margaret-atwood) * ![](/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto,quality=75,width=1920,fit=scale-down/https://images.ctfassets.net/v44fuld738we/1T70dSMrba2hOqfZWHwXlE/3192615673f05be864f86bf73005004c/ShtNoOneKnows_1900x1900_Magazine_Square.jpg) Finance for Humans [Five Tax Enigmas That Confuse Basically Everyone](/en-ca/magazine/canadian-tax-stuff-nobody-knows) OK, OK: they’re not technically enigmas, but these are the things most likely to trip you up when it comes time to file. We make sense of the madness and hopefully spare you some confusion. * ![](/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto,quality=75,width=1920,fit=scale-down/https://images.ctfassets.net/v44fuld738we/5GxVjRQ0TyJrvMCwFFMb85/7e2d72d5297f59c6954fac854ec2388a/BondDrop23_1900x1900_Magazine.jpg) Finance for Humans [The Bond Market Fell, Hard. An Explainer for Normal Humans](/en-ca/magazine/bond-explainer) A steep selloff in government securities has unnerved Wall Street — and made individual investors question whether bonds are even worth holding anymore. Here’s what’s going on. * Wealthsimple ### Grow your money Smart investing tools and personalized advice designed to build long term wealth. [Get started](/en-ca) ![](/build-assets/_next/static/media/generation-background.818a9430.jpg) * ![](/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto,quality=75,width=1920,fit=scale-down/https://images.ctfassets.net/v44fuld738we/6yBcbBc5ndkBsPWUgKAY8Y/334510f001d570138406d2265eec7d7a/TaxFreelancer_1900x1900_Magazine_Square_Small.jpg) Finance for Humans [A Freelancer’s Guide to Saving Like a Corporate Lifer](/en-ca/magazine/freelancer-taxes-canada) Self-employment comes with a lot of perks, mostly involving not having a boss. The tradeoff? No savings or retirement benefits. Womp womp. That means freelancers need to create their own savings strategy. Here’s how. * ![](/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto,quality=75,width=1920,fit=scale-down/https://images.ctfassets.net/v44fuld738we/4mWRAolqCgtLbZoIwNSZGa/534ea437f65fb7ec04d0f9389f3a9b3c/Perfect_Guide_1900x1900_Magazine_Square.jpg) Finance for Humans [The Perfect Guide to Every Little Tax Question You Have](/en-ca/magazine/tax-questions-canada) Or at least the 13 most common, thorny questions. We assembled our Wealthsimple Tax team to answer everything you were afraid to look up on the internet — and we promise the answers are easy to understand. Show me more ![](/build-assets/_next/static/media/generation-background.818a9430.jpg) Wealthsimple ## Grow your money Smart investing tools and personalized advice designed to build long term wealth. [Get started](/en-ca)